Feingold questions Petraeus

Can we clone Senator Feingold - please?

Indiana will take two. Thank you.



UPDATE: I just found out that two of the seven soldiers who authored this New York Times op-ed "The War as We Saw It" died yesterday in a vehicle accident in Iraq. One of them, Sgt. Mora, was due to return home in November.

Several Senators, including Senator Chuck Hagel, spoke highly of the op-ed and the soldiers who wrote it during the hearings - asking who the Senate should be expected to believe, the soldiers who fought in Iraq, or Petraeus?

Meanwhile, Petraeus never mentioned that two of them had just died, the previous day.

He obviously knew about the accident... he mentions it at the end of this YouTube video.

Did he know that two of the op-ed writers died in that accident? Their obituaries had already run in their hometown newspapers (Staff Sergeant Yance Gray, Sergeant Omar Mora) by the time of the hearings. Their names were out - to the general public. How could Petraeus not know?

And imagine the embarrassment had this come out in the hearings...

The Pentagon doesn't have a very good track record of letting on that they know information that will be damaging to their case (Tillman, Lynch.) And because of this past behavior, I no longer give them the benefit of the doubt.

Petraeus will most likely have known their names IF their names were on that op-ed writers' list, because someone from below would have freaked and sent the news up through the ranks. The Pentagon PR people were undoubtedly going crazy.

Or... perhaps not. Perhaps Petraeus 'wouldn't recall' their names anyway. Perhaps such a high ranking general wouldn't care about individual names. Which is worse - that he knew and didn't say, or that he didn't know because nobody cared?

I just hope he was squirming like hell when the Senators were talking about these guys. If two out of seven guys who write an op-ed can't even get home alive... yeah, surge is going just great. Hopefully the rest will make it out of, as Senator Hagel puts it, that 'meat-grinder.'

Ashcroft refused to authorize warrantless wiretapping

I've never been a big fan of John Ashcroft.

However in light of recent testimony to the Senate Judiciary Committee by former Deputy Attorney General James Comey... I'm seeing John Ashcroft in a whole new light.

According the testimony by Comey, Ashcroft was so offended when he discovered that the Bush Administration had initiated a program of warrentless wiretapping on American citizens in 2004, that he was actually prepared to resign in protest. Other members of the Defense Department also threatened to resign, along with FBI Director Robert Mueller.

Ashcroft apparently believes in the sanctity of the Constitution.

This would not have come as a shock to us in 2004. We were still innocent then. Long ago - in 2004 - most of us still believed that all of our legislators adhered to the Constitution, on which they had taken their oath of office.

Compared with Bush, Cheney and gang, Ashcroft seems almost heroic in the stand he took against warrantless wiretapping during his watch. And he did manage to squelch it, at least for awhile. Or at least the most blatantly illegal portions of it, the portions that were completely indefensible. Exactly what any of this entailed is, of course, secret. Everything that involves our Constitutional rights - completely secret. And whatever Ashcroft managed to avoid for us only lasted until Alberto Gonzales took over.

The story that came out in Comey's testimony, of Ashcroft - lying sick in a hospital bed with pancreatitis in March of 2004 - is startling in its coldly calculated attempt at manipulation.

Apparently, the GOP does eat its own.

Comey told Congress that Ashcroft refused to sign off on the spying campaign because he believed it was unconstitutional (proving once and for all that the Justice Department, at least initially, believed the surveillance program to be illegal.)

Comey then told the Justice Committee a little story.

It seems that then White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales and White House chief of staff Andrew Card actually tried to coerce Ashcroft into re-authorizing the program as he lay seriously ill in a hospital bed with pancreatitis, after then acting-Attorney General Comey (who was covering for him in his absence,) refused to sign off on the program.

Apparently hoping to catch Ashcroft at an unguarded moment while he was sick and perhaps incognizant, Gonzales and Card raced to the hospital in an attempt to get Ashcroft to sign from his hospital bed. When Comey discovered their plan, he too raced to the hospital, arriving ahead of them to support Ashcroft.

From McClatchy:

The Bush administration ran its warrantless eavesdropping program without the Justice Department's approval for up to three weeks in 2004, nearly triggering a mass resignation of the nation's top law enforcement officials, the former No. 2 official disclosed Tuesday.

In testimony to the Senate Judiciary Committee, former Deputy Attorney General James Comey said that those he believed were prepared to quit included then-Attorney General John Ashcroft and FBI Director Robert Mueller.

Comey said then-White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales and former White House Chief of Staff Andrew Card visited Ashcroft as he lay gravely ill in a hospital bed on March 10, 2004, and pressed him to re-certify the program's legality. Ashcroft refused.

"I was angry. I thought I had just witnessed an effort to take advantage of a very seriously sick man, who did not have the powers of the attorney general because they had been transferred to me," Comey recalled. "I thought it was improper."

Comey, who'd assumed Ashcroft's powers on an acting basis, had raced ahead of Gonzales and Card to the George Washington University Hospital, his car's emergency lights flashing, and dashed up the stairs to Ashcroft's room, trailed by his security detail.

"That night was probably the most difficult time of my professional life," Comey recalled.

Senator Russ Feingold (D-WI) called Comey's words "some of the most powerful testimony I've heard in 25 years as a legislator." Senator Arlen Specter (R-PA), a long time critic of the eavesdropping program, praised Comey for standing up to the White House.